Boxiecat Scent Free is a bentonite clay litter, and Noisy Lion is a tofu litter made from pea fibre with bentonite added. In the 1–3 star reviews of Boxiecat on Amazon.ca, a common complaint we found is litter tracked through the house (16 of 41 we read). Tofu litter tracks less than clay; the granules are larger and lighter. Our tofu line also has an independent lab report from CTI showing 99.9% dust-free and 99.1% odour removal.
tofu litter
Scent Free Clumping Clay
Boxiecat details from petsmart.ca (Boxiecat Scent Free Clumping Clay, 28 lb) and boxiecat.com, checked November 5, 2026. Noisy Lion figures from our product pages and CTI report A2260218535101001E (tofu line). Complaint counts: we read 41 of the most helpful and most recent 1–3 star reviews of Boxiecat clay litter on Amazon.ca on November 8, 2026. They are a share of those critical reviews, not of all buyers.
Why people choose Noisy Lion
Less litter tracked through the house
Boxiecat’s site says “LOW DUST, LESS TRACKING.” Tracking still came up in 16 of the 41 critical reviews we read. Tofu litter tracks less than clay; the granules are larger and lighter.
“Despite their claims, this litter is high tracking.”3-star review on Amazon.ca, January 2026
“I have 3 cats and they like it too. Very little tracking.”Verified buyer, noisylion.ca, August 2026
Dust you can check
CTI, an independent lab, measured 0.1% powder content in our tofu line, which is 99.9% dust-free. The same test found 99.1% odour removal. You can read the report. Boxiecat claims 99.9% dust-free as well. We didn’t find a test method or lab report on its listing.
“It clumps fast, controls smell, and is almost dust-free.”Verified purchase, Walmart.ca, December 2025
Clumps that come out in one piece
Our tofu litter clumps faster and harder than clay. The bentonite helps each clump hold together, so it lifts out whole. We test all our litters in mainstream automatic litter boxes.
“Very effective cat litter, no smell, absorbs odors, and clumps well.”Verified purchase, Walmart.ca, December 2025
Where the used litter goes
The Scent Free listing at PetSmart.ca doesn’t say whether it can be flushed. Boxiecat’s directions for its BoxiePro clay litter say to put it in the trash and not flush it. With our tofu litter, you can flush a few clumps at a time if your municipality allows it. Never flush on a septic system, and never flush our cassava line. Our disposal guide covers the other options.
When Boxiecat is the better fit
Choose Boxiecat if price per kilo matters most. At PetSmart the Scent Free 28 lb (12.7 kg) bag was $49.99 on November 5, 2026. That is about $3.94 a kilo, against $4.92 for our 12 kg bag, or $4.42 on subscription. Boxiecat Scent Free has no added fragrance, and some Boxiecat litters include probiotics.
Questions people ask
What is Boxiecat made of?
Boxiecat says its litters are mainly natural sodium bentonite clay. The Scent Free listing at PetSmart says 100% bentonite clay. Our tofu litter is pea fibre and plant starches, with bentonite added. Our Natural Cassava line has no bentonite.
What do Boxiecat buyers complain about?
We read 41 critical (1–3 star) reviews of Boxiecat clay litter on Amazon.ca on November 8, 2026. Price or the litter running out fast came up in 20, tracking in 16 and dust in 12. Tofu litter tracks less than clay; the granules are larger and lighter. For dust, CTI found our tofu line 99.9% dust-free, and the report is on our site.
Which controls odour better?
Both brands say they control odour. Ours was tested by CTI, an independent lab. It removed 99.1% of odour in the test of our tofu line. Boxiecat lists 40-day odour control. We didn’t find a lab report behind it.
Is Boxiecat cheaper than Noisy Lion?
Per kilo, a little. At PetSmart the 28 lb Scent Free bag was $49.99 (about $3.94 a kilo) on November 5, 2026. Our 12 kg bag is $4.92 a kilo, or $4.42 on subscription.
Does Noisy Lion work in automatic litter boxes?
We test all our litters in mainstream automatic litter boxes. Boxiecat says its Scent Free litter works in regular, sifting and automatic boxes too.
Boxiecat information comes from petsmart.ca, petsmart.com and boxiecat.com, checked November 5, 2026. Complaint counts come from Amazon.ca reviews read November 8, 2026. Boxiecat’s current prices and terms take precedence. Customer quotes are individual experiences. Noisy Lion lab figures are for our tofu line (CTI report A2260218535101001E). Boxiecat is a trademark of its owner; this article is not affiliated with or endorsed by Boxiecat.