Tidy Cats LightWeight is a Purina clay litter, and Noisy Lion is a tofu litter made from pea fibre with bentonite added. In the 1–3 star reviews of Tidy Cats LightWeight on Amazon.ca, the most common complaint we found is litter tracked through the house (16 of 35 we read). Tofu litter tracks less than clay; the granules are larger and lighter. Our tofu line also has an independent lab report from CTI showing 99.9% dust-free and 99.1% odour removal.
tofu litter
LightWeight clay litter
Tidy Cats details from petsmart.ca (Tidy Cats LightWeight 24/7 Performance Multi-Cat, 5.44 kg and 7.71 kg) and Purina’s Tidy Cats FAQ, checked November 5, 2026. Noisy Lion figures from our product pages and CTI report A2260218535101001E (tofu line). Complaint counts: we read 35 of the most helpful and most recent 1–3 star reviews of Tidy Cats LightWeight Free & Clean on Amazon.ca on November 8, 2026. They are a share of those critical reviews, not of all buyers.
Why people choose Noisy Lion
Less litter tracked through the house
Tracking was the complaint we saw most in critical reviews of Tidy Cats LightWeight. Tofu litter tracks less than clay; the granules are larger and lighter. Ours are pea fibre and plant starches, with bentonite added.
“One trip in and out if her litter box and it tracks over my entire house!!”1-star review on Amazon.ca, December 2024
“My cat hardly tracks any litter through the house after use. Controls odour.”Verified purchase, Walmart.ca, March 2026
A dust figure you can look up
CTI, an independent lab, measured 0.1% powder content in our tofu line, which is 99.9% dust-free. The same test found 99.1% odour removal. You can read the report. The Tidy Cats listing at PetSmart says “low dust for a clean, easy pour.” It gives no percentage, and we didn’t find a lab report.
“Love this cat litter...NO dust. NO odor.”Verified purchase, Amazon.ca, January 2026
Fast, firm clumps
Our tofu litter clumps faster and harder than clay. The bentonite helps each clump hold together, so it lifts out whole.
“It absorbs odor really well, clumps firmly, and doesn’t stick to my cat’s paws.”Verified purchase, Walmart.ca, February 2026
Switching from clay
If your cat is used to clay, mix the new litter in a little at a time. Our 10-day switching guide walks you through it.
“…great for clumping and helps take care of smells. My cat switched no problem.”Verified buyer, noisylion.ca, June 2026
When Tidy Cats is the better fit
Choose Tidy Cats if price per kilo matters most. At PetSmart the LightWeight 24/7 Performance 7.71 kg pail was $30.99 on November 5, 2026. That is about $4.02 a kilo, against $4.92 for our 12 kg bag. Tidy Cats says LightWeight is 50% lighter than the leading clumping litter.
Questions people ask
Is Tidy Cats a clay litter?
PetSmart lists the material of Tidy Cats LightWeight 24/7 Performance as clay. Our tofu litter is pea fibre and plant starches, with bentonite added. Our Natural Cassava line has no bentonite.
What do Tidy Cats buyers complain about?
We read 35 critical (1–3 star) reviews of Tidy Cats LightWeight Free & Clean on Amazon.ca on November 8, 2026. Tracking came up in 16, litter sticking to paws and fur in 12, and dust in 9. Tofu litter tracks less than clay; the granules are larger and lighter. For dust, CTI found our tofu line 99.9% dust-free, and the report is on our site.
Which controls odour better?
Both brands say they control odour. Ours was tested by CTI, an independent lab. It removed 99.1% of odour in the test of our tofu line. Tidy Cats offers a 3-week guarantee against ammonia odour. We didn’t find a lab report behind it.
Is Tidy Cats cheaper than Noisy Lion?
Per kilo, a little. At PetSmart on November 5, 2026 the 7.71 kg pail was $30.99 (about $4.02 a kilo) and the 5.44 kg pail $24.99 (about $4.59 a kilo). Our 12 kg bag is $4.92 a kilo, or $4.42 on subscription, which is under the smaller pail.
Can I flush Tidy Cats or Noisy Lion?
Purina’s Tidy Cats FAQ says its litter is not flushable. You can flush a few clumps of our tofu litter at a time if your municipality allows it, but never on a septic system. Never flush our cassava line. See our disposal guide.
Tidy Cats information comes from petsmart.ca listings and Purina’s Tidy Cats FAQ, checked November 5, 2026. Complaint counts come from Amazon.ca reviews read November 8, 2026. Purina’s current prices and terms take precedence. Customer quotes are individual experiences. Noisy Lion lab figures are for our tofu line (CTI report A2260218535101001E). Tidy Cats and Purina are trademarks of their owner; this article is not affiliated with or endorsed by Purina.